The danger of fire was one of the ways in which Pinchot convinced a reluctant Congress to fund his corps of green shirted rangers. The danger was not illusory. In 1871, the Pestigo fire in Wisconsin burned over a million acres and killed 1,182 people. In Minnesota in 1894, another tragic fire struck which killed 413 people. Pinchot knew that fire was necessary and in some cases beneficial to forests and understood that nature could never be completely controlled. His fire control efforts started a debate which continues to this day as to where to draw that line.
The rangers on the front lines were highly motivated by poorly paid; a miserable salary even for the day of $900 per year. Pinchot’s directions to them on fighting fires were simple. As he told the New York Times, “the one secret to fighting fires is to discover your fire as soon as possible and fight it as hard as you can and refuse to leave it until the last ember is dead.” The Forest Service had some successes in their first two summers as only one tenth of one percent (0.1%) of Forest Service land burned each year. There were bad years as well, however.
One of the assistant rangers hired in the Bitterroot area was Ed Pulaski. He was older than most of the Yale Forestry program graduates initially hired by Pinchot, but a skilled outdoorsman. The man himself, who died in 1931, is little known, but his name lives on as the inventor of the tool still in use today—the Pulaski tool.
Successors to Pinchot such as Bill Greeley took his concerns and tactics on fire and elevated them in priority increasing the Forest Service role in prevention and suppression efforts. The debate continues over the proper level of these, but forgotten by many is that man with who it began, Pennsylvanian Gifford Pinchot.